Detecting Causal Chains in Small-N Data
نویسنده
چکیده
The first part of this paper shows that Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA)—also in its most recent form as presented in Ragin (2008)—, does not correctly analyze data generated by causal chains. The incorrect modeling of data originating from chains essentially stems from QCA’s reliance on Quine-McCluskey optimization to eliminate redundancies from sufficient and necessary conditions. Baumgartner (2009a,b) has introduced a Boolean methodology, termed Coincidence Analysis (CNA), that is related to QCA, yet, contrary to the latter, does not eliminate redundancies by means of Quine-McCluskey optimization. The second part of the paper applies CNA to chain-generated data. It will turn out that CNA successfully detects causal chains in small-N data.
منابع مشابه
Empirical Bayes Estimation in Nonstationary Markov chains
Estimation procedures for nonstationary Markov chains appear to be relatively sparse. This work introduces empirical Bayes estimators for the transition probability matrix of a finite nonstationary Markov chain. The data are assumed to be of a panel study type in which each data set consists of a sequence of observations on N>=2 independent and identically dis...
متن کاملRunning head: TRANSITIVE REASONING IN CAUSAL CHAINS Transitive Reasoning Distorts Induction in Causal Chains
A probabilistic causal chain ABC may intuitively appear to be transitive: If A probabilistically causes B, and B probabilistically causes C, A probabilistically causes C. However, probabilistic causal relations are only transitive if the so-called Markov condition holds. In two experiments, we examined how people make probabilistic judgments about indirect relationships AC in causal chains A...
متن کاملApplications of Beamlets to Detection and Extraction of Lines, Curves and Objects in Very Noisy Images
Beamlets are a special dyadically organized collection of line segments, exhibiting a range of lengths, positions and orientations. This collection is relatively compact: there are O(n log2(n)) beamlets, compared to O(n) line segments. This collection is relatively expressive: up to a certain tolerance, it does not take more than O(log2(n)) beamlets to approximate a single line segment. Because...
متن کاملA Transitivity Heuristic of Probabilistic Causal Reasoning
In deterministic causal chains the relations „A causes B’ and „B causes C’ imply that „A causes C’. However, this is not necessarily the case for probabilistic causal relationships: A may probabilistically cause B, and B may probabilistically cause C, but A does not probabilistically cause C, but rather ¬C. The normal transitive inference is only valid when the Markov condition holds, a key fea...
متن کاملInformative Interventions
Causal discovery programs have met with considerable enthusiasm in the AI and data mining communities. Amongst philosophers they have met a more mixed response, with numerous skeptics pointing out weaknesses in their assumptions. Some criticize the reliance upon faithfulness (the idea that every causal connection will result in probabilistic dependence), since the true model may in fact be unfa...
متن کامل